Past Performance Is No Guarantee of Future Returns

Why do investors believe the opposite of the truth?

November 2026:

 

Do you invest in the stock market? Do you believe that past performance is no guarantee of future returns, and then behave as if it is?

'Past performance is no guarantee of future returns'. We've all seen this mantra on financial investment services websites, perhaps put there at the behest of nervous lawyers. It's undeniably true: despite what anyone may claim, we can't see into the future. Yet this small but honest statement is routinely ignored by the vast majority of investors, by you and by me. If anyone berates me with a version of this claim, I would ask 'Why do you invest?' The answer is would probbaly be along the lines of 'Because over a period of time the stock market has produced better returns than savings.' There couldn't be a better example of past performance influencing future returns than this. In 2026 the UK government tried to persuade those who still had any spare money left to invest in stocks rather than in a savings account, sold to the public on the grounds that investments can provide greater growth. Even the government believes in the magic of past performance. The whole investment edifice is built on the belief that past performance predicts - if not guarantees - future returns.

Of course investors don't just use past performance to select particular stocks. Whether a bubble is about to be created, or burst, new developments, wars, shortages and surpluses, the weather, all can influence stock selection. Yet it's not the event that's being used to determine which stock to invest in but the perceived reaction of the market to the event. Do you expect the stock to rise or fall? What did stocks do last time the evnt happened? What does past performance rell you?

Outside the world of investment, past performance is called experience, either gained personally or second-hand through various resources. All my adult life has ben swayed and shaped by experience, it determines what car I buy, what television programmes I watch, where I live, what job I have, even my friends and, dare I say it, my spouse. Consciously or not, everything I do is formed by past performance in the guise of experience. Everything that is happening or has happened in the world is in the past, we learn from it, and copy it, and expect the same reaction in the future. The past is all we have.

Past performance is why I have a flat white instead of a latte, why I don't believe in God, why I invest in global index funds, and why Kim Jong-un would like to kill me.

 

 

You can return to my home page here

If you have any questions, comments or criticisms at all then I'd be pleased to hear them: please email me at kes at kcall dot co dot uk.

© Webmaster. All rights reserved.